When they all support the LGBTIQ++ community and trans individuals, it is because many of these players push themselves to the limit in the gym to look like men—destroying their female bodies—simply because they are lesbians. In the U.S., sports have been turned into a breeding ground and a hub for the spread of lesbianism.
The example set by the WNBA in supporting the so-called "LGBTIQ++ community"—which is, in reality, a lobby (one of its founders was the rabid queer Andy Warhol, though it was truly established by the Rockefellers—they called it a "Movement")—is disgusting. Can you imagine if the media talked about a "hetero community," with "heteros," "heteros++," and "hyper-heteros"? It would be just as ridiculous. Why should children have to see the "wife" of the lesbian player Bonner, or be forced to listen to these LGBTIQ++ speeches during game breaks?
This is the example the U.S. sets for the world... And things got much worse when they placed a rabid lesbian at the helm of Disney to indoctrinate and corrupt children. It’s disgusting! It’s horrible! Women’s sports are no longer sports; they have become LGBTIQ++ propaganda aimed at everyone—it’s truly repulsive. There is no longer any respect for childhood; they want to corrupt children as early as possible.
When you hear the dreadful U.S. national anthem, remember their genocides across the globe and their satanic LGBTIQ++ propaganda—a country of gay pirates!
In the U.S., the LGBTIQ++ agenda is everywhere—it’s as if you were to quit smoking, only to find that every time you step outside, people are smoking all around you, forcing you to inhale their noxious fumes.
I agree totally. I have no problem including trans people almost everywhere, except on the playing field, where biological differences not only give them an unfair advantage but present a danger to biological females.
When San Luis Obispo, California, became the first city in America to ban smoking in restaurants and bars, we heard this same deliberately dishonest gaslighting: "If they can ban smoking, they can ban *you*!"
Bullshit. Nobody got banned. Only their cancer-sticks--and them only when lit. Fast-forward to today, and smoking indoors is banned everywhere.
Do lesbians really, sincerely believe they'll lose their rights as lesbians if they stand up to straight men LARPing as "lesbians"? Or does it make more sense that they'll actually lose their rights as lesbians by SUBMITTING to the straight men LARPing as "lesbians"?
Any time oppressors want to enlist the support of the oppressed, they threaten greater oppression: "Agree with those of us in power, or you'll be oppressed even WORSE. Trust us--it's for your own good!"
TQ+ "spicy straights" and poseurs may abandon the WNBA, but lesbians will not, for multiple reasons. They may fear being expelled from the alphabet mafia's hostage situation, but will not abandon women's sport when the WNBA adapts an IOC-style sex-verification policy, just as they did not abandon the Women's Tennis Association, World Aquatics, World Athletics or any of the other international sporting bodies who have returned to sex-verification testing in 2026.
Kerry Sweet is now blocked. Thanks Brian Erb and Lisa Simeone, for calling it. Too bad the simple word lesbian attracts misogynist trolls as well as fetishists but... it does. At least I/we can effectively set certain boundaries.
I have responded to numerous other Substack posts with why I felt including men in women sports was short-changing women. But until I just read your story I couldn't articulate the reasons why I thought it was happening. Which goes further to explain why we see it in women's sports, but not men's. Again thank you thank you thank you.
Do you think perhaps that when people are focusing more on those issues (inclusion, acceptance, and belonging), that it might be because those issues are more important to them overall?
Regardless of what someone thinks about who competes in which category in elite competitive sports, some may feel more strongly about the ability of all people to be included, accepted, and find a sense of belonging *in society at large*.
Perhaps your priority is very specifically about the women's sports category and access to women's spaces. (Or at least it used to be.) But that doesn't mean that is the shared priority of all lesbians, or even all lesbian athletes. Different people have all different reasons why they might choose to speak out (or not) about one topic or angle over another.
The majority of people I hear talking the loudest about saving the women's sports category are neither athletes nor lesbians. So many people who never cared about women's sports are suddenly amplifying this very specific debate about women's sports categories all over social media and in every room they enter, as though their reasons are pure and genuinely pro-women. Do you believe that? Do you believe this issue is being used by *some* (many) people for reasons quite different than your own? That for some people, this is the quickest way to turn the tides they want to turn in politics, and pit people against one another?
And even if it is not *your* motivation (I hope), do you believe that this issue is being used - specifically by people who support the current administration - as rage bait to further divide and weaken the LGBTQ community?
You have said you don't align with right wing politics. I get that. But can you see where someone might feel that this issue is being used by the right in this way, and that this could compromise the safety of a lot of people? And perhaps that might motivate someone to speak about the importance of inclusion and acceptance and belonging, even if they're not advocating for anything different about the sports categories? Could it be that people are just genuinely responding to all of the negativity swirling around in society right now about the larger community?
You guess at a few reasons in this article of why you feel some lesbians in the WNBA might be talking about this focus instead of talking about the sports category eligibility rules. The reasons you guess at seem to be assuming motivation of self-preservation or status. Could it be that perhaps they feel threatened by the way society is shifting more and more toward anti-LGBTQ sentiments overall? And that they might feel more compelled to speak out about larger discrimination outside of the sports arena, rather than focusing on a small number of people within it?
(Please note that I am not here to argue or to trade "gotcha" takes on any of your actual positions on issues. That's counterproductive, and not my reason for posing the questions. I am genuinely asking these questions in response to your article.)
My take on this controversy is this.: At the beginning, most TERFs were asking very little and asking for it reasonably. But after being deluged by threats and insults, many of them sickeningly sexually violent, most TERFs understandably dug in their heels and refused to even consider the possibility of compromise. From "please don't lock up sex offenders in women's prisons just because they say they are women”. They have gone to "all trans people are delusional psychopaths, and all gender affirming care is criminal mutilation.” Each side now insists that the other must use language that one side rejects as delusional, which makes talking to each other impossible.
I like the word TERFs, and I'm glad that most TERFs have not rejected it, because it reminds me that the people I am talking to are in fact, Radical Feminists. I have no interest in speaking to MAGA Idiots who think there are passages in the Bible condemning transness or think that makes any difference. If you are a TERF, then you have more in common with the trans activists than you do with MAGA. And so I say to both trans activists and TERFs "I realize this issue is important to you, but it is not that important to the rest of us. Aren’t you more concerned about the fact that American democracy is being destroyed, that people are being kidnapped off the street and/or killed by government thugs etc.? The Republicans are using this issue to pick up votes in red states, and progressive Democrats are using this issue to nominate candidates that will not appeal to independents. It is highly likely that this could contribute to two more years of Republican majorities in Congress, and an election by a Trump 2.0 candidate as the next president.
So in the name of all that is just and decent, will you guys please stop squabbling and come up with a compromise that neither of you will be completely satisfied with, but both of you could live with. Stop saying things like "I can't argue with someone who doesn't accept reality". That statement may look reasonable to you, but the fact is all arguments arise only because people on different sides disagree about reality. There's nothing else to argue about. Reality is all that there is.
However, the fundamental principle of secular democracy, is that people with radically different views of reality can agree to disagree and work together. That’s what we need now, instead of non-negotiable demands. If we cannot learn to do that, We have given up on Democracy itself, and we may lose it.
When I hear the word "inclusion", I want to reach for my gun. Which I don't have, of course, so I'll just say this: Including males in girls' sports EX-cludes the girls.
About being marginalised: the people most marginalised and oppressed in this world are Afghan women. Period.
There's at least one white man who claims to be a Muslim woman. The one that comes to mind is Alice Avizandum. Of course, as with the other aspects of female subjugation they fetishize, he's not actually required to wear a headscarf, etc. or be beaten, so he can just get off to the idea of being oppressed (he once Tweeted something vile along these lines but I can't remember enough to try and find it).
Since close to 100% of WNBA players come from college basketball and the NCAA doesn't allow transgender athletes, could someone tell me where this transgender player everyone is worrying about will come from? It is highly unlikely a team will ever draft one. I'd bet it is an unwritten rule. This whole controversy is posturing and virtue signaling.
NCAA DOES allow transgender athletes - so long as they play in the proper sex category, like everyone else. Lots of players come from overseas, not the NCAA. And we’re not worried about “transgender players,” we’re worried about males - who have invaded all women’s sports at all levels in many countries. You don’t wait to lock the door until after the theft happens. You lock the door just in case. Sports orgs always define eligibility clearly: Only people under 12 years old, only double amputees, only people who weigh less than 120 pounds, only females — then verify. On our side, no one is posturing or virtue signaling. We just care about fairness for girls and women.
I agree with your theory. Great article! It’s about finding your tribe and not wanting to be ostracized.
I argue that the L Word needs to consider who it most aligned with at this point and who will stand to protect us. Feminists for certain. Almost every lesbian I know is a feminist by default - because we had to fight for equal rights as women to survive. Finding prince charming to support us was not an option for us.
I believe there has been an overall failure by the G word to take a collective stance to protect women and, especially, lesbians. This doesn’t surprise me because I’ve known few gay men who were feminists and some of the worst misogynists I’ve known have been gay men. Many have not been supportive of lesbians and there is a sad history of gay men excluding lesbians from their nightclubs and social events. Unless, of course, you were a “lipstick lesbian” and fit with their version of what a woman should look like. Even then, many gay men preferred to surround themselves with fawning straight women who desired them. We had a name for these types of women which I will not repeat. Think Julianna Moore in “A Single Man” or the female leads in Will and Grace and you got it.
We share only same sex attraction with gay men. We have always been very different than them in our social needs, interests and desires. Same thing can be said for heterosexuals - they share only exclusive opposite sex attraction. Yet we do not put heterosexual men and women in an alphabet soup and refer to their civil rights as a collective. Men and women are different and this fact should IMO be celebrated.
Without meaning to stereotype lesbians, I believe we likely share more in common with straight men than we do gay men. We are both exclusively attracted to females; most of us adore and respect women (especially the “lioness” types who are strong women and who will defend the “pride” from harm … we would not have survived as a species without both sexes working together in my view); we tend to love sports, cars and many of us excel at fixing stuff. I have always said “you want to build a house you call the lesbians, you want to plan a fab brunch you call the gay men”. I see more of a natural alliance with straight men than I do gay men and, just sayin’, I’m looking more at the ‘good ones’ (the big brother or Dad Girl types) to have my back if it gets any worse.
It has always seemed to me that lesbians and gay men, far from being the same demographic, are in fact opposites.
Straight people are the muddle in the middle: half female, half male. As someone said in a movie: “God[dess] and the Devil trying to work things out.” 😜
We are no different in our needs and desires IMO than males and females. I agree we are opposites in many ways and often struggle to understand each other just like men and women do.
IMO, gay men have always held privileges we didn’t have simply because they are men. Throughout history we’ve seen many coddled by women who tend more to protect them because they have had a hard time. I would argue we weren’t as coddled so there is often an independence and strength amongst lesbians because we had to find our own way through life in a cruel world. For example, how much representation has there been of straight women all wanting to have a gay male best friend?
The history of gay men controlling women’s fashion and how we should look, dress and act has always fascinated me. If straight woman want to know what looks hot on them or what men desire to attract the opposite sex, it seems to be they should ask men who actually desire them and not have Ru Paul dress them or style their hair. We consistently see straight men answer differently than gay men in what is attractive to them with respect to females.
Most lesbians I know really love the company of many straight men and do not hate men. Though we do not desire them sexually, I find most straight men also like having a lesbian friend where the pressure is off them to not have to perform to a male stereotypes and they can just be themselves once sex is off the table. Most of us grew up “tomboys” so we played with boys, got along well with boys and liked “boy” things.
Gay men have ALWAYS had access to male income and fame. ALWAYS. Alexander the Great subjugated an entire part of the world as a gay man. And don't even get me started on the professional, financial, and social success of gay men in my own field: the arts.
I've read that pedophilic gay men perved the women's fashion industry into mimicking what *they* sexually desire: teenage boys. It makes sense.
The truth is that a gay male couple has twice as much access to male income as a straight couple. And a lesbian couple has zero access to it.
There's a reason why men like Tim Gill and Jon Stryker have the millions to sink into the "transgenderism" lobby (as well as completely altering the political makeup of the entire state of Colorado). And it's not because they're suffering from oppression against gay men.
If we're going to talk about oppression, let's talk about one of the major oppressions of all societies throughout all history: poverty. Lesbians suffer from it. Straight single women suffer from it. Straight single mothers definitely suffer from it. Gay men most definitely do NOT.
“We share only same sex attraction with gay men. We have always been very different than them in our social needs, interests and desires. Same thing can be said for heterosexuals - they share only exclusive opposite sex attraction. Yet we do not put heterosexual men and women in an alphabet soup and refer to their civil rights as a collective.” - good point!
(I have far more in common with women than straight men, but interesting perspective.)
I think many of us are used to men wanting to have sex with us. Why any person would want to have sex with another person who doesn’t desire them is beyond my scope of comprehension.
But, yes, it pisses me off when men say they’re lesbians. Used to be the oldest joke in the lesbian attempted pick up book when men would walk up to a group of group of hot lesbians and declare they were a lesbian too. Why, I’d ask? Because I like chicks too, they’d answer. We used to laugh about it because everyone got the joke. It wasn’t until recent times when it stopped being a joke - when people called us hateful and “sexual racists” for not wanting to shag the opposite sex.
Can you imagine homos lobbing this bomb at heterosexuals and declaring them hateful and “sexual racists” for not wanting to shag us? That wouldn’t stick for one second.
Five or six years ago when I was still a shiny, new TERF, full of optimism, I honestly thought this was all going to come to a head when they demanded to be in lesbian bars and dating apps and tried to force young lesbians into non consensual sex with the threat of being labeled "transphobic". I thought the rape adjacence would be the end of their demands to be treated as though they were actually women. Then I slowly came to the realization that many if not most lesbians stood up for them. Aah, the naivety of middle age.
BTW in college, in a Psychology of Sex Roles class with Sandra Bem, I teamed up with a short man to co-author a research paper on how short men and tall women were affected by what we then called sex roles: all those expectations, stereotypes, etc. Surveyed a lot of students. One conclusion I recall: The short men had a harder time socially, and it affected their self-confidence more.
I haven’t read too deeply here…mostly scanned the comments…but I think this is more a heterosexual issue. However, that can complicate the situation for the tall heterosexual women and short heterosexual men. Some gay men love shorter guys! But there’s enough residual homophobia out there that Mr 5’5” heterosexual dude isn’t helped by the knowledge that his height wouldn’t be an issue if he was gay.
Fascinating. I agree. It should come as no surprise that most men who make it to CEO status are most often tall men. We’ve all born witness to men competing for attention and to be heard in a room of other men and I’ve seen shorter men literally stand on a chair to be seen as the tallest men who will command the most attention. Never seen shorter women exhibit this tendency. Or the tendency for women to make themselves appear bigger or do the primal chest bump thing.
We are told when encountering a predator (could be a bear) who might attack us in the wild to “make ourselves look bigger”. It is a survival instinct - look to the one in your tribe who’s the biggest and strongest for protection. But I believe the kings of the jungle are the Lion family who learn to work together. Remarkable story I saw recently of a Silverback Guerilla rescuing 4 orphaned lion cubs and raising and protecting them. Lessons to be learned there I think. If you’re interested and need a good cry 👇
Oh, dear. I asked google if it's true that a gorilla named Musafa raised four lion cubs, and it led me to a whole list of similar AI-generated videos about various and sundry gorillas of both sexes raising lion cubs in different numbers. Either AI has discovered a whole subculture of gorillas raising lion cubs, or I'm afraid this is probably a hoax. 🤷♀️
Thanks for this. I'll watch it because I like gorilla stories and also lioness stories, but I'm already laughing uncontrollably at the over-the-top melodrama of the narrative:
"a sound so desperate, so raw, that it cut through the thick jungle air like nothing I'd ever heard before. It was a cry--no, it was more than that, it was the sound of four tiny lives screaming into the darkness"
Baby lions don't scream. They squeak. Certainly, their tiny voices couldn't cut through thick jungle air like nothing anyone had ever heard before. . .unless perhaps you've never before heard squeaking. 🤣
Great! I would love to see the "males must be taller than women they date" mandate go the way of the dinosaur. So much sexism embedded in that expectation.
Yes: And it often takes them by surprise, because they can't tell from the profile pic necessarily with dating apps, and have to quietly discern it for themselves in person, once they're sitting at a coffee shop or whatever. False advertising at its most pernicious.
Fine if the wnba wants to be a club not a money making business based on skill. Not even mentioning the W part; kinda seems that is an issue if you want to have women’s sports and not the B team of men who can’t make it in their own league.
“You are perfect as you are.” So tell me again why gender nonconforming children need to be drugged, their natural development interfered with, fed wrong-sex hormones and have healthy body parts amputated so that they become castrated and sterilised (aka “gender-affirming healthcare”).
Loved this! This is yet another consequence of the political merging of LGB with every other sexual minority on the planet. But your article also signals a way sporting federations can frame their statements if and when they revert to using biological reality to ascertain eligibility: you all belong, you’re part of our tribe, we see you AND we need coherent and fair eligibility criteria.
What we are not aware of is that portions of our population have been indoctrinated inside Queer patriarchy for years. All those indoctrinated inside Queer patriarchy is done so regardless of sex, race, social class and sexual orientation. All on the far left were indoctrinated.
Our western universities need a complete overhaul. The inundation of critical theory into every aspect of their curriculum has been a stupendous disservice to all of our young people.
I really appreciate your thoughtful analysis of an issue that evokes great passion. I also admire your courage to tackle the issue head on.I particularly applaud your ability to raise arguments with which you disagree and then refute them in an artful and respectful way. I am also drawn to your point that "exclusion is not hatred." I am going to try to memorize that phrase.
When they all support the LGBTIQ++ community and trans individuals, it is because many of these players push themselves to the limit in the gym to look like men—destroying their female bodies—simply because they are lesbians. In the U.S., sports have been turned into a breeding ground and a hub for the spread of lesbianism.
The example set by the WNBA in supporting the so-called "LGBTIQ++ community"—which is, in reality, a lobby (one of its founders was the rabid queer Andy Warhol, though it was truly established by the Rockefellers—they called it a "Movement")—is disgusting. Can you imagine if the media talked about a "hetero community," with "heteros," "heteros++," and "hyper-heteros"? It would be just as ridiculous. Why should children have to see the "wife" of the lesbian player Bonner, or be forced to listen to these LGBTIQ++ speeches during game breaks?
This is the example the U.S. sets for the world... And things got much worse when they placed a rabid lesbian at the helm of Disney to indoctrinate and corrupt children. It’s disgusting! It’s horrible! Women’s sports are no longer sports; they have become LGBTIQ++ propaganda aimed at everyone—it’s truly repulsive. There is no longer any respect for childhood; they want to corrupt children as early as possible.
When you hear the dreadful U.S. national anthem, remember their genocides across the globe and their satanic LGBTIQ++ propaganda—a country of gay pirates!
In the U.S., the LGBTIQ++ agenda is everywhere—it’s as if you were to quit smoking, only to find that every time you step outside, people are smoking all around you, forcing you to inhale their noxious fumes.
I agree totally. I have no problem including trans people almost everywhere, except on the playing field, where biological differences not only give them an unfair advantage but present a danger to biological females.
When San Luis Obispo, California, became the first city in America to ban smoking in restaurants and bars, we heard this same deliberately dishonest gaslighting: "If they can ban smoking, they can ban *you*!"
Bullshit. Nobody got banned. Only their cancer-sticks--and them only when lit. Fast-forward to today, and smoking indoors is banned everywhere.
Do lesbians really, sincerely believe they'll lose their rights as lesbians if they stand up to straight men LARPing as "lesbians"? Or does it make more sense that they'll actually lose their rights as lesbians by SUBMITTING to the straight men LARPing as "lesbians"?
Any time oppressors want to enlist the support of the oppressed, they threaten greater oppression: "Agree with those of us in power, or you'll be oppressed even WORSE. Trust us--it's for your own good!"
That's not logic.
That's a threat.
TQ+ "spicy straights" and poseurs may abandon the WNBA, but lesbians will not, for multiple reasons. They may fear being expelled from the alphabet mafia's hostage situation, but will not abandon women's sport when the WNBA adapts an IOC-style sex-verification policy, just as they did not abandon the Women's Tennis Association, World Aquatics, World Athletics or any of the other international sporting bodies who have returned to sex-verification testing in 2026.
Agreed.
Kerry Sweet is now blocked. Thanks Brian Erb and Lisa Simeone, for calling it. Too bad the simple word lesbian attracts misogynist trolls as well as fetishists but... it does. At least I/we can effectively set certain boundaries.
Yes, yes, yes! And thank you!
I have responded to numerous other Substack posts with why I felt including men in women sports was short-changing women. But until I just read your story I couldn't articulate the reasons why I thought it was happening. Which goes further to explain why we see it in women's sports, but not men's. Again thank you thank you thank you.
You're very welcome, Ray. Glad to have you on the team. :-)
Do you think perhaps that when people are focusing more on those issues (inclusion, acceptance, and belonging), that it might be because those issues are more important to them overall?
Regardless of what someone thinks about who competes in which category in elite competitive sports, some may feel more strongly about the ability of all people to be included, accepted, and find a sense of belonging *in society at large*.
Perhaps your priority is very specifically about the women's sports category and access to women's spaces. (Or at least it used to be.) But that doesn't mean that is the shared priority of all lesbians, or even all lesbian athletes. Different people have all different reasons why they might choose to speak out (or not) about one topic or angle over another.
The majority of people I hear talking the loudest about saving the women's sports category are neither athletes nor lesbians. So many people who never cared about women's sports are suddenly amplifying this very specific debate about women's sports categories all over social media and in every room they enter, as though their reasons are pure and genuinely pro-women. Do you believe that? Do you believe this issue is being used by *some* (many) people for reasons quite different than your own? That for some people, this is the quickest way to turn the tides they want to turn in politics, and pit people against one another?
And even if it is not *your* motivation (I hope), do you believe that this issue is being used - specifically by people who support the current administration - as rage bait to further divide and weaken the LGBTQ community?
You have said you don't align with right wing politics. I get that. But can you see where someone might feel that this issue is being used by the right in this way, and that this could compromise the safety of a lot of people? And perhaps that might motivate someone to speak about the importance of inclusion and acceptance and belonging, even if they're not advocating for anything different about the sports categories? Could it be that people are just genuinely responding to all of the negativity swirling around in society right now about the larger community?
You guess at a few reasons in this article of why you feel some lesbians in the WNBA might be talking about this focus instead of talking about the sports category eligibility rules. The reasons you guess at seem to be assuming motivation of self-preservation or status. Could it be that perhaps they feel threatened by the way society is shifting more and more toward anti-LGBTQ sentiments overall? And that they might feel more compelled to speak out about larger discrimination outside of the sports arena, rather than focusing on a small number of people within it?
(Please note that I am not here to argue or to trade "gotcha" takes on any of your actual positions on issues. That's counterproductive, and not my reason for posing the questions. I am genuinely asking these questions in response to your article.)
My take on this controversy is this.: At the beginning, most TERFs were asking very little and asking for it reasonably. But after being deluged by threats and insults, many of them sickeningly sexually violent, most TERFs understandably dug in their heels and refused to even consider the possibility of compromise. From "please don't lock up sex offenders in women's prisons just because they say they are women”. They have gone to "all trans people are delusional psychopaths, and all gender affirming care is criminal mutilation.” Each side now insists that the other must use language that one side rejects as delusional, which makes talking to each other impossible.
I like the word TERFs, and I'm glad that most TERFs have not rejected it, because it reminds me that the people I am talking to are in fact, Radical Feminists. I have no interest in speaking to MAGA Idiots who think there are passages in the Bible condemning transness or think that makes any difference. If you are a TERF, then you have more in common with the trans activists than you do with MAGA. And so I say to both trans activists and TERFs "I realize this issue is important to you, but it is not that important to the rest of us. Aren’t you more concerned about the fact that American democracy is being destroyed, that people are being kidnapped off the street and/or killed by government thugs etc.? The Republicans are using this issue to pick up votes in red states, and progressive Democrats are using this issue to nominate candidates that will not appeal to independents. It is highly likely that this could contribute to two more years of Republican majorities in Congress, and an election by a Trump 2.0 candidate as the next president.
So in the name of all that is just and decent, will you guys please stop squabbling and come up with a compromise that neither of you will be completely satisfied with, but both of you could live with. Stop saying things like "I can't argue with someone who doesn't accept reality". That statement may look reasonable to you, but the fact is all arguments arise only because people on different sides disagree about reality. There's nothing else to argue about. Reality is all that there is.
However, the fundamental principle of secular democracy, is that people with radically different views of reality can agree to disagree and work together. That’s what we need now, instead of non-negotiable demands. If we cannot learn to do that, We have given up on Democracy itself, and we may lose it.
I'm going to respond at length in tomorrow morning's post. Thanks for these thought-provoking questions.
These are fair questions. I’ll think about it and get back to you.
When I hear the word "inclusion", I want to reach for my gun. Which I don't have, of course, so I'll just say this: Including males in girls' sports EX-cludes the girls.
About being marginalised: the people most marginalised and oppressed in this world are Afghan women. Period.
And zero men fetishize burkas.
Don't be so sure. ;)
Ha.
There's at least one white man who claims to be a Muslim woman. The one that comes to mind is Alice Avizandum. Of course, as with the other aspects of female subjugation they fetishize, he's not actually required to wear a headscarf, etc. or be beaten, so he can just get off to the idea of being oppressed (he once Tweeted something vile along these lines but I can't remember enough to try and find it).
Since close to 100% of WNBA players come from college basketball and the NCAA doesn't allow transgender athletes, could someone tell me where this transgender player everyone is worrying about will come from? It is highly unlikely a team will ever draft one. I'd bet it is an unwritten rule. This whole controversy is posturing and virtue signaling.
NCAA DOES allow transgender athletes - so long as they play in the proper sex category, like everyone else. Lots of players come from overseas, not the NCAA. And we’re not worried about “transgender players,” we’re worried about males - who have invaded all women’s sports at all levels in many countries. You don’t wait to lock the door until after the theft happens. You lock the door just in case. Sports orgs always define eligibility clearly: Only people under 12 years old, only double amputees, only people who weigh less than 120 pounds, only females — then verify. On our side, no one is posturing or virtue signaling. We just care about fairness for girls and women.
I agree with your theory. Great article! It’s about finding your tribe and not wanting to be ostracized.
I argue that the L Word needs to consider who it most aligned with at this point and who will stand to protect us. Feminists for certain. Almost every lesbian I know is a feminist by default - because we had to fight for equal rights as women to survive. Finding prince charming to support us was not an option for us.
I believe there has been an overall failure by the G word to take a collective stance to protect women and, especially, lesbians. This doesn’t surprise me because I’ve known few gay men who were feminists and some of the worst misogynists I’ve known have been gay men. Many have not been supportive of lesbians and there is a sad history of gay men excluding lesbians from their nightclubs and social events. Unless, of course, you were a “lipstick lesbian” and fit with their version of what a woman should look like. Even then, many gay men preferred to surround themselves with fawning straight women who desired them. We had a name for these types of women which I will not repeat. Think Julianna Moore in “A Single Man” or the female leads in Will and Grace and you got it.
We share only same sex attraction with gay men. We have always been very different than them in our social needs, interests and desires. Same thing can be said for heterosexuals - they share only exclusive opposite sex attraction. Yet we do not put heterosexual men and women in an alphabet soup and refer to their civil rights as a collective. Men and women are different and this fact should IMO be celebrated.
Without meaning to stereotype lesbians, I believe we likely share more in common with straight men than we do gay men. We are both exclusively attracted to females; most of us adore and respect women (especially the “lioness” types who are strong women and who will defend the “pride” from harm … we would not have survived as a species without both sexes working together in my view); we tend to love sports, cars and many of us excel at fixing stuff. I have always said “you want to build a house you call the lesbians, you want to plan a fab brunch you call the gay men”. I see more of a natural alliance with straight men than I do gay men and, just sayin’, I’m looking more at the ‘good ones’ (the big brother or Dad Girl types) to have my back if it gets any worse.
It has always seemed to me that lesbians and gay men, far from being the same demographic, are in fact opposites.
Straight people are the muddle in the middle: half female, half male. As someone said in a movie: “God[dess] and the Devil trying to work things out.” 😜
We are no different in our needs and desires IMO than males and females. I agree we are opposites in many ways and often struggle to understand each other just like men and women do.
IMO, gay men have always held privileges we didn’t have simply because they are men. Throughout history we’ve seen many coddled by women who tend more to protect them because they have had a hard time. I would argue we weren’t as coddled so there is often an independence and strength amongst lesbians because we had to find our own way through life in a cruel world. For example, how much representation has there been of straight women all wanting to have a gay male best friend?
The history of gay men controlling women’s fashion and how we should look, dress and act has always fascinated me. If straight woman want to know what looks hot on them or what men desire to attract the opposite sex, it seems to be they should ask men who actually desire them and not have Ru Paul dress them or style their hair. We consistently see straight men answer differently than gay men in what is attractive to them with respect to females.
Most lesbians I know really love the company of many straight men and do not hate men. Though we do not desire them sexually, I find most straight men also like having a lesbian friend where the pressure is off them to not have to perform to a male stereotypes and they can just be themselves once sex is off the table. Most of us grew up “tomboys” so we played with boys, got along well with boys and liked “boy” things.
Gay men have ALWAYS had access to male income and fame. ALWAYS. Alexander the Great subjugated an entire part of the world as a gay man. And don't even get me started on the professional, financial, and social success of gay men in my own field: the arts.
I've read that pedophilic gay men perved the women's fashion industry into mimicking what *they* sexually desire: teenage boys. It makes sense.
The truth is that a gay male couple has twice as much access to male income as a straight couple. And a lesbian couple has zero access to it.
There's a reason why men like Tim Gill and Jon Stryker have the millions to sink into the "transgenderism" lobby (as well as completely altering the political makeup of the entire state of Colorado). And it's not because they're suffering from oppression against gay men.
If we're going to talk about oppression, let's talk about one of the major oppressions of all societies throughout all history: poverty. Lesbians suffer from it. Straight single women suffer from it. Straight single mothers definitely suffer from it. Gay men most definitely do NOT.
“We share only same sex attraction with gay men. We have always been very different than them in our social needs, interests and desires. Same thing can be said for heterosexuals - they share only exclusive opposite sex attraction. Yet we do not put heterosexual men and women in an alphabet soup and refer to their civil rights as a collective.” - good point!
(I have far more in common with women than straight men, but interesting perspective.)
Me too. Funny thing that.
:-)
I think many of us are used to men wanting to have sex with us. Why any person would want to have sex with another person who doesn’t desire them is beyond my scope of comprehension.
But, yes, it pisses me off when men say they’re lesbians. Used to be the oldest joke in the lesbian attempted pick up book when men would walk up to a group of group of hot lesbians and declare they were a lesbian too. Why, I’d ask? Because I like chicks too, they’d answer. We used to laugh about it because everyone got the joke. It wasn’t until recent times when it stopped being a joke - when people called us hateful and “sexual racists” for not wanting to shag the opposite sex.
Can you imagine homos lobbing this bomb at heterosexuals and declaring them hateful and “sexual racists” for not wanting to shag us? That wouldn’t stick for one second.
Removed a question by a man about lesbian sex preferences. Just no.
I trust your judgment and to hold the line, champ. “Just no”.
Thank you.
Five or six years ago when I was still a shiny, new TERF, full of optimism, I honestly thought this was all going to come to a head when they demanded to be in lesbian bars and dating apps and tried to force young lesbians into non consensual sex with the threat of being labeled "transphobic". I thought the rape adjacence would be the end of their demands to be treated as though they were actually women. Then I slowly came to the realization that many if not most lesbians stood up for them. Aah, the naivety of middle age.
Regrettably not. I too thought it to be would a stop block moment.
BTW in college, in a Psychology of Sex Roles class with Sandra Bem, I teamed up with a short man to co-author a research paper on how short men and tall women were affected by what we then called sex roles: all those expectations, stereotypes, etc. Surveyed a lot of students. One conclusion I recall: The short men had a harder time socially, and it affected their self-confidence more.
I haven’t read too deeply here…mostly scanned the comments…but I think this is more a heterosexual issue. However, that can complicate the situation for the tall heterosexual women and short heterosexual men. Some gay men love shorter guys! But there’s enough residual homophobia out there that Mr 5’5” heterosexual dude isn’t helped by the knowledge that his height wouldn’t be an issue if he was gay.
Fascinating. I agree. It should come as no surprise that most men who make it to CEO status are most often tall men. We’ve all born witness to men competing for attention and to be heard in a room of other men and I’ve seen shorter men literally stand on a chair to be seen as the tallest men who will command the most attention. Never seen shorter women exhibit this tendency. Or the tendency for women to make themselves appear bigger or do the primal chest bump thing.
We are told when encountering a predator (could be a bear) who might attack us in the wild to “make ourselves look bigger”. It is a survival instinct - look to the one in your tribe who’s the biggest and strongest for protection. But I believe the kings of the jungle are the Lion family who learn to work together. Remarkable story I saw recently of a Silverback Guerilla rescuing 4 orphaned lion cubs and raising and protecting them. Lessons to be learned there I think. If you’re interested and need a good cry 👇
https://youtu.be/h8jmxQmXNUM?si=yBVraC3UIIkNiZjc
Oh, dear. I asked google if it's true that a gorilla named Musafa raised four lion cubs, and it led me to a whole list of similar AI-generated videos about various and sundry gorillas of both sexes raising lion cubs in different numbers. Either AI has discovered a whole subculture of gorillas raising lion cubs, or I'm afraid this is probably a hoax. 🤷♀️
Thanks for this. I'll watch it because I like gorilla stories and also lioness stories, but I'm already laughing uncontrollably at the over-the-top melodrama of the narrative:
"a sound so desperate, so raw, that it cut through the thick jungle air like nothing I'd ever heard before. It was a cry--no, it was more than that, it was the sound of four tiny lives screaming into the darkness"
Baby lions don't scream. They squeak. Certainly, their tiny voices couldn't cut through thick jungle air like nothing anyone had ever heard before. . .unless perhaps you've never before heard squeaking. 🤣
Great! I would love to see the "males must be taller than women they date" mandate go the way of the dinosaur. So much sexism embedded in that expectation.
Yes: And it often takes them by surprise, because they can't tell from the profile pic necessarily with dating apps, and have to quietly discern it for themselves in person, once they're sitting at a coffee shop or whatever. False advertising at its most pernicious.
WNBA referees need to be arrested and jailed.
Fine if the wnba wants to be a club not a money making business based on skill. Not even mentioning the W part; kinda seems that is an issue if you want to have women’s sports and not the B team of men who can’t make it in their own league.
“You are perfect as you are.” So tell me again why gender nonconforming children need to be drugged, their natural development interfered with, fed wrong-sex hormones and have healthy body parts amputated so that they become castrated and sterilised (aka “gender-affirming healthcare”).
Loved this! This is yet another consequence of the political merging of LGB with every other sexual minority on the planet. But your article also signals a way sporting federations can frame their statements if and when they revert to using biological reality to ascertain eligibility: you all belong, you’re part of our tribe, we see you AND we need coherent and fair eligibility criteria.
Exactly. Belonging is different from eligibility rules.
What we are not aware of is that portions of our population have been indoctrinated inside Queer patriarchy for years. All those indoctrinated inside Queer patriarchy is done so regardless of sex, race, social class and sexual orientation. All on the far left were indoctrinated.
Our western universities need a complete overhaul. The inundation of critical theory into every aspect of their curriculum has been a stupendous disservice to all of our young people.
Queer Patriarchy. 🎯 Love it, loved your speech at ICONS, which I recommend people go watch on YouTube.
I really appreciate your thoughtful analysis of an issue that evokes great passion. I also admire your courage to tackle the issue head on.I particularly applaud your ability to raise arguments with which you disagree and then refute them in an artful and respectful way. I am also drawn to your point that "exclusion is not hatred." I am going to try to memorize that phrase.
Yay. Thanks so much, Judy. 💜🙏