Not surprised that some leading “trans” activists feel they have “lost control of the narrative”. Perhaps if they’d hadn’t stayed silent for so long when they could see people being viciously attacked/sued/in some cases murdered/arrested/excluded from civil society for having a dissenting viewpoint, things would be different. Maybe they should have spoken out when it became evident the civil rights of others were being eroded or lost. When your arguments get caught in lies and contradictions, it never seems to bode well for “controlling the narrative” which I feel they have done for far too long.
Too little too late? Because now is the time for them to collectively rise and walk it back IMO.
So — yes, “nonbinary” is a category based solely on gender stereotypes, the kind of stereotypes feminists have tried for decades to quash. Now those shibboleths have been weaponized against children.
I suppose we could be grateful that this category exists as a waystation for kids who are confused but not so confused that they want puberty-blocking drugs, genital mutilation, and surgery to remove healthy, functioning organs. They can emerge on the other side with their bodies and sexual functions intact.
Or there’s the cynical view that… it’s trans on the cheap. Join the club, but no need to pay the dues.
Unfortunately, the most common so-called gender- affirming care surgery is an unnecessary double mastectomy. These are usually girls who identify as non-binary.
Thank you for noting this. It’s tragic that young women would go to this length to escape their sex (or whatever is driving this). I remember sitting next to a young detransitioner who had written and talked about how awful the experience of getting a bilateral mastectomy was, how dismissive the surgeon was, about dealing with the post-op drains. All I could think was, I wish I’d had the opportunity to let her what this would involve before she took this disastrous step. But I also knew, at the time she made this choice, that she wouldn’t have listened. As she explained, there was no alternative point of view within her peer group. So terribly sad.
Here’s another question: You and others have cited statistics saying that 59% of “trans” people are “nonbinary.” Can anyone tell me what “nonbinary” means? And is it a category based on anymore than exaggerated caricatures of gender stereotypes?
I would add an important correction here , it is LIBERAL women who are "protective" towards trans , not conservative , or possibly even independent aligned women. Would it then be fair to say that conservative women feel protective towards girls and women? I don't think this gets clarified nearly enough , and it's an important distinction if you are going to talk about this. Not all women are the same , as not all men are the same.
When I hear people babble about "inclusion" all I can think of is junior high school when it mattered whether or not you were "popular." I'd like to think that adult women have progressed beyond that junior high mentality, but maybe some don't.
Yeah, and they don't mean "inclusion where he actually belongs," like at a cafeteria table. They mean "inclusion where he does not belong," like a women's restroom.
Quote: "A 10-year-old, 15-year-old, or 20-year-old nephew can announce that he is now a 'trans girl.' But he cannot expect his aunt to believe he is now female. Nor to invite him to a swimming pool, escort him into the women’s locker room, strip off her clothes in front of him, and permit him to strip in front of the girls and women sharing that space. That’s not cruelty. It’s a legitimate boundary."
I just had this exact conversation with a friend. She had texted me:
"Two masculine looking female gay women friends get harassed in the women’s bathroom. And then where is my trans nephew who identifies and looks like a woman supposed to do when nature calls. Chances are that using a men’s room could be dicey."
I replied:
"I bet your 'masculine-looking female gay friends' never got harassed in all the years before this 'trans' insanity took over. And your nephew, whatever his age, is still a boy/man and belongs in the men’s room. He isn’t 'trans'. He’s emotionally disturbed and needs help. Women aren’t support animals for confused/disturbed men! Why should we have to give up our safe single-sex spaces for men??"
I have gotten harassed (and even had security called, over 30 years ago) for going in and out of the women's room in public places. I have also seen people pull their kids back and stop them from going into a women's bathroom when they saw me going in there. (Not sure if it's because they thought I was a man or if it's because they thought I was a lesbian. But either way, they clearly saw me as a danger because of my appearance.) So yes, it does happen, and it has happened for many, many years.
Also, why is the men's room automatically dismissed as dicey? Men aren't hanging out in there waiting to pounce on anyone who looks like a woman. Women use them sometimes if they can't handle the line for the Women's (it is polite to knock and explain the situation and give the men a heads up and zip up) I've known some pretty effeminate men - never a problem for them.
I've gone into the men's myself - usually because some restaurant or bar decided on cutesy signs and eh, wrong guess. No problems, just a few guys pointing to the Women's and sympathizing about the dumb confusing signs.
The concept leans *hard* on the listener's presumption that of course men would immediately harm any effeminate man* in the men's room. However, I can't recall ever hearing about this happening. And don't you think if it had, TRAs would be talking about it constantly?
I agree. We also should consider that we still have not managed to get women's bathroom that are really adequate for women's specific biological needs and social roles (or anything close to adequate capacity). Seems more like some "clever" engineer looked at the men's room, realized that women don't pee standing up and squirting outward, and removed urinals from the men's design. And that's it. Actual female needs got us the occasional empty tampon dispenser at the sink or near the door (more likely to find condoms available than tampons), and a cganging station wedged somewhere high traffic and inaccessible. We were already juggling need, privacy, and dignity to make the current situation work. And now there's a new factor that makes that juggling untenable for many.
I also wonder how much "now women have trouble if they don't look feminine" is simply people punishing women for transgressing the little gender boxes - recognizing that they are women and punishing them for being female but not "feminine".
Frankly, I doubt the story that butch-looking women are being harassed in women's restrooms. I need to see some proof.
In all these years it hasn't been a problem and now suddenly it is? Come on.
Meanwhile, men are invading women's restrooms and locker rooms and women are rightly afraid of them. When women do report them, they're told to shut up and put up with it. Management sides with the opposite-sex imposters. There have been countless stories about this (even given the press's usual reluctance to report this stuff) and lawsuits against these institutions, such as gyms and health clubs.
And while the discussion has largely focused on peeing, most women will also menstruate for a number of years during their lifetimes. Current restrooms do a piss poor job (sic) of addressing periods. It isn't always a neat little process, easily managed by a few products in your pocket or bag. If a woman needs the sink to clean up, real privacy is ideal. Real privacy us rarely available, so single sex is the minimum servicable option.
My young adult son helpfully suggested the other day that everyone use enclosed single-person stalls.
So I explained to him that stalls were designed specifically so that a girl or woman could not be trapped in one by a man. I also explained that taking care of menstruation issues can't always be done in a stall--sometimes it involves washing out a piece of clothing--and it can't always be done alone--sometimes you need another woman with a tampon or advice or, god forbid, help in a medical emergency. And, finally, female-only spaces serve as essential havens for girls and women escaping predatory boys and men. We need them in our public lives. Girls and young women, in particular, can't get by without them.
These are not things that boys and men know about. But girls and women do.
My son commented that the propagandists online never educate young men on these issues, so they don't even know they're a part of the conversation. (Until, of course, their mothers and sisters tell them.)
What's even more gobsmacking these days is that free tampons are being provided IN MEN'S RESTROOMS. I just saw a story the other day about a school district that has mandated that tampons be provided for the boys, because "people" menstruate, dontchyaknow?!
I saw one story, one, that seemed credible. It was an account by a trans identfied femal (transman) who decided to use the restroom for her sex and claimed she was beaten by men for that. Her claim was that they saw a man entering the wrong bathroom. I find that framing unlikely, because it assumes two unlikely things:
That she actually passes for male
That random groups of men actually beat up other men for hassling unrelated women in private spaces.
I think it is more likely that, if this happened, the men clocked her as female. Not unlikely.
And the men saw an opportunity and excuse to punish a transgressive female. Not unlikely.
I've never had trouble identifying butch women as women. For whatever reason they tend to be pretty short (one of life's ironies). They also tend to be female shaped with female faces. Female woman people have an extra layer of fat that softens our features, the sharpness of our musculature and bone structure etc.
I'm not saying it's impossible because almost anything's possible, but I don't buy it. Sounds like an apocryphal story ginned up by a "trans ally" as propaganda.
I'm with you. Highly unlikely "that random groups of men actually beat up other men for hassling unrelated women in private spaces." As if. And even when aberrations happen, they're not worth rearranging entire social conventions in response.
Not surprised that some leading “trans” activists feel they have “lost control of the narrative”. Perhaps if they’d hadn’t stayed silent for so long when they could see people being viciously attacked/sued/in some cases murdered/arrested/excluded from civil society for having a dissenting viewpoint, things would be different. Maybe they should have spoken out when it became evident the civil rights of others were being eroded or lost. When your arguments get caught in lies and contradictions, it never seems to bode well for “controlling the narrative” which I feel they have done for far too long.
Too little too late? Because now is the time for them to collectively rise and walk it back IMO.
So — yes, “nonbinary” is a category based solely on gender stereotypes, the kind of stereotypes feminists have tried for decades to quash. Now those shibboleths have been weaponized against children.
I suppose we could be grateful that this category exists as a waystation for kids who are confused but not so confused that they want puberty-blocking drugs, genital mutilation, and surgery to remove healthy, functioning organs. They can emerge on the other side with their bodies and sexual functions intact.
Or there’s the cynical view that… it’s trans on the cheap. Join the club, but no need to pay the dues.
Unfortunately, the most common so-called gender- affirming care surgery is an unnecessary double mastectomy. These are usually girls who identify as non-binary.
Thank you for noting this. It’s tragic that young women would go to this length to escape their sex (or whatever is driving this). I remember sitting next to a young detransitioner who had written and talked about how awful the experience of getting a bilateral mastectomy was, how dismissive the surgeon was, about dealing with the post-op drains. All I could think was, I wish I’d had the opportunity to let her what this would involve before she took this disastrous step. But I also knew, at the time she made this choice, that she wouldn’t have listened. As she explained, there was no alternative point of view within her peer group. So terribly sad.
Yes.
Here’s another question: You and others have cited statistics saying that 59% of “trans” people are “nonbinary.” Can anyone tell me what “nonbinary” means? And is it a category based on anymore than exaggerated caricatures of gender stereotypes?
Yes. Here’s what non-binary means:
https://strongerwomen.substack.com/p/what-does-non-binary-mean
Good stuff. So important to keep the dialog going.
I would add an important correction here , it is LIBERAL women who are "protective" towards trans , not conservative , or possibly even independent aligned women. Would it then be fair to say that conservative women feel protective towards girls and women? I don't think this gets clarified nearly enough , and it's an important distinction if you are going to talk about this. Not all women are the same , as not all men are the same.
You are consistently level-headed, and we are lucky to have your voice.
Thank you, Susan! I try. :-)
Great piece. Now someone needs to write an article titled “Lesbians Have a Trans Problem.” For generations we’ve debated and dealt with this crap.
Send me a draft. :-)
When I hear people babble about "inclusion" all I can think of is junior high school when it mattered whether or not you were "popular." I'd like to think that adult women have progressed beyond that junior high mentality, but maybe some don't.
Yeah, and they don't mean "inclusion where he actually belongs," like at a cafeteria table. They mean "inclusion where he does not belong," like a women's restroom.
Quote: "A 10-year-old, 15-year-old, or 20-year-old nephew can announce that he is now a 'trans girl.' But he cannot expect his aunt to believe he is now female. Nor to invite him to a swimming pool, escort him into the women’s locker room, strip off her clothes in front of him, and permit him to strip in front of the girls and women sharing that space. That’s not cruelty. It’s a legitimate boundary."
I just had this exact conversation with a friend. She had texted me:
"Two masculine looking female gay women friends get harassed in the women’s bathroom. And then where is my trans nephew who identifies and looks like a woman supposed to do when nature calls. Chances are that using a men’s room could be dicey."
I replied:
"I bet your 'masculine-looking female gay friends' never got harassed in all the years before this 'trans' insanity took over. And your nephew, whatever his age, is still a boy/man and belongs in the men’s room. He isn’t 'trans'. He’s emotionally disturbed and needs help. Women aren’t support animals for confused/disturbed men! Why should we have to give up our safe single-sex spaces for men??"
I have gotten harassed (and even had security called, over 30 years ago) for going in and out of the women's room in public places. I have also seen people pull their kids back and stop them from going into a women's bathroom when they saw me going in there. (Not sure if it's because they thought I was a man or if it's because they thought I was a lesbian. But either way, they clearly saw me as a danger because of my appearance.) So yes, it does happen, and it has happened for many, many years.
It's still more dangerous for women in women's restrooms and locker rooms to be accosted by men. Men don't belong there.
Also, why is the men's room automatically dismissed as dicey? Men aren't hanging out in there waiting to pounce on anyone who looks like a woman. Women use them sometimes if they can't handle the line for the Women's (it is polite to knock and explain the situation and give the men a heads up and zip up) I've known some pretty effeminate men - never a problem for them.
I've gone into the men's myself - usually because some restaurant or bar decided on cutesy signs and eh, wrong guess. No problems, just a few guys pointing to the Women's and sympathizing about the dumb confusing signs.
The concept leans *hard* on the listener's presumption that of course men would immediately harm any effeminate man* in the men's room. However, I can't recall ever hearing about this happening. And don't you think if it had, TRAs would be talking about it constantly?
And I will add, in my more naive days, I believed this too!
They would be on blast if the effeminate man could be spun as trans. If it were just a plain old gay or straight man, crickets.
You're not wrong! Effeminate gay or straight men are not of the chosen caste at this time.
I agree. We also should consider that we still have not managed to get women's bathroom that are really adequate for women's specific biological needs and social roles (or anything close to adequate capacity). Seems more like some "clever" engineer looked at the men's room, realized that women don't pee standing up and squirting outward, and removed urinals from the men's design. And that's it. Actual female needs got us the occasional empty tampon dispenser at the sink or near the door (more likely to find condoms available than tampons), and a cganging station wedged somewhere high traffic and inaccessible. We were already juggling need, privacy, and dignity to make the current situation work. And now there's a new factor that makes that juggling untenable for many.
I also wonder how much "now women have trouble if they don't look feminine" is simply people punishing women for transgressing the little gender boxes - recognizing that they are women and punishing them for being female but not "feminine".
Frankly, I doubt the story that butch-looking women are being harassed in women's restrooms. I need to see some proof.
In all these years it hasn't been a problem and now suddenly it is? Come on.
Meanwhile, men are invading women's restrooms and locker rooms and women are rightly afraid of them. When women do report them, they're told to shut up and put up with it. Management sides with the opposite-sex imposters. There have been countless stories about this (even given the press's usual reluctance to report this stuff) and lawsuits against these institutions, such as gyms and health clubs.
And while the discussion has largely focused on peeing, most women will also menstruate for a number of years during their lifetimes. Current restrooms do a piss poor job (sic) of addressing periods. It isn't always a neat little process, easily managed by a few products in your pocket or bag. If a woman needs the sink to clean up, real privacy is ideal. Real privacy us rarely available, so single sex is the minimum servicable option.
Just one example.
My young adult son helpfully suggested the other day that everyone use enclosed single-person stalls.
So I explained to him that stalls were designed specifically so that a girl or woman could not be trapped in one by a man. I also explained that taking care of menstruation issues can't always be done in a stall--sometimes it involves washing out a piece of clothing--and it can't always be done alone--sometimes you need another woman with a tampon or advice or, god forbid, help in a medical emergency. And, finally, female-only spaces serve as essential havens for girls and women escaping predatory boys and men. We need them in our public lives. Girls and young women, in particular, can't get by without them.
These are not things that boys and men know about. But girls and women do.
My son commented that the propagandists online never educate young men on these issues, so they don't even know they're a part of the conversation. (Until, of course, their mothers and sisters tell them.)
What's even more gobsmacking these days is that free tampons are being provided IN MEN'S RESTROOMS. I just saw a story the other day about a school district that has mandated that tampons be provided for the boys, because "people" menstruate, dontchyaknow?!
We are living in Bizarro World.
I saw one story, one, that seemed credible. It was an account by a trans identfied femal (transman) who decided to use the restroom for her sex and claimed she was beaten by men for that. Her claim was that they saw a man entering the wrong bathroom. I find that framing unlikely, because it assumes two unlikely things:
That she actually passes for male
That random groups of men actually beat up other men for hassling unrelated women in private spaces.
I think it is more likely that, if this happened, the men clocked her as female. Not unlikely.
And the men saw an opportunity and excuse to punish a transgressive female. Not unlikely.
I've never had trouble identifying butch women as women. For whatever reason they tend to be pretty short (one of life's ironies). They also tend to be female shaped with female faces. Female woman people have an extra layer of fat that softens our features, the sharpness of our musculature and bone structure etc.
Yeah, I don't buy it.
I'm not saying it's impossible because almost anything's possible, but I don't buy it. Sounds like an apocryphal story ginned up by a "trans ally" as propaganda.
Women who have deliberately made themselves look like men have NO business in women-only spaces.
You don’t get to make yourself look like the sex that is a verifiable danger to girls and women and then enter our safe spaces.
It’s called living with the consequences of your own actions.
Don’t want to look like your own sex? Pee the fuck at home.
I'm with you. Highly unlikely "that random groups of men actually beat up other men for hassling unrelated women in private spaces." As if. And even when aberrations happen, they're not worth rearranging entire social conventions in response.